View Single Post
  #170 (permalink)  
Old 04-27-2008, 02:06 AM
Elphaba's Avatar
Elphaba Elphaba is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: United States -
Posts: 6,096
Thanks: 1,907
Thanked 1,401 Times in 742 Posts
Laughs: 727
Laughs at 613 Times in 302 Posts
Send a message via AIM to Elphaba Send a message via MSN to Elphaba
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Fiannan View Post
Oh Elphaba, leaving yourself open again. Oh well.
I've posted your original comment below which I have challenged. It is also the only claim I have discussed in my posts.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Fiannan View Post
They [US government] thought placing a military outpost filled with dashing single men would lure these poor women out of this horrible cult. Emphasis mine.
As I stated before, this is not true. I also stated you would not be able to provide credible proof it was true.

Your most recent post to me has proven me right. The following are my responses to your post:
Quote:
On the points you attacked me on:
Military presence in Utah:
Utah Expedition
How does this link prove the US sent "dashing single men" to Utah outposts to lure Utah woman away. There is nothing even close to your assertion in this article.
Quote:
Military outposts were abandoned once the Civil War became a reality.
How does this prove the US sent "dashing single men" to the outposts to lure Utah women to them?

Quote:
Point #2:

Not able to discuss specifics since Skip replied to a long post by just saying his ancestors were somewhere without dealing with any specific fact. Ball was in Sip's court and here you were looking for it in mine?
How do these comments prove the US sent "dashing single men" to Utah outposts?

Quote:
Point #3:

Say what? Again, I commented that the US government and a large segment of the US population threw the same chastizements against the LDS Church in the 19th. Century as are being thrown at the FLDS today. Well duh, anyone with any knowledge of Utah history knows that. What, the next time someone ways that a lot of innocent people died in WW2 you'll call for their names and citizenships?
How does this prove the US sent "dashing single men" to Utah, in the 19th century, to lure women away.

I'll stop now as I think my point is made. You are wont to write posts, often provocative ones that make wild claims. Yet when asked for credible proof of your comments, you provide useless links, blame other people for your inability to provide the proof, and use diversions, shifting the conversation to other issues that have nothing to do with the subject of the discussion.

But you never provide the credible proof. That is because you never have any.

I hope others see how they need to be wary of Fiannan's claims.

Elphaba
__________________
We can't change the country.
Let us change the subject.
Stephen Dedalus,
Ulysses